When you're thinking about adding a pool to your backyard, you might wonder whether an above ground pool or an in ground pool is the better choice. Both have their unique benefits and drawbacks, and the right option depends on your budget, space, and lifestyle. In this article, I’ll help you understand the main differences so you can make a confident decision.
We’ll look at costs, installation, maintenance, durability, and how each pool type fits different needs. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of what to expect from above ground and in ground pools, making it easier to pick the perfect pool for your home.
Cost Differences Between Above Ground and In Ground Pools
One of the biggest factors when choosing a pool is cost. Above ground pools are generally much cheaper than in ground pools. This makes them a popular choice for families or individuals on a budget.
- Above Ground Pools: Typically cost between $1,500 and $7,000, including installation. You can find smaller models for under $2,000, while larger or more elaborate setups may approach $7,000.
- In Ground Pools: Usually range from $30,000 to $70,000 or more. The price depends on size, shape, materials (concrete, vinyl, fiberglass), and additional features like lighting or heating.
The lower price of above ground pools comes from simpler installation and less expensive materials. In ground pools require excavation, plumbing, and professional construction, which drives up the cost.
If you want a pool but don’t want to spend a fortune, an above ground pool is a great starting point. However, if you’re ready to invest in a permanent backyard feature, an in ground pool offers more long-term value.
Installation Time and Complexity
How quickly you want your pool ready to use can influence your choice. Above ground pools are much faster and easier to install.
- Above Ground Pools: Installation can take just a few days. Most kits come with clear instructions, and you can even assemble some models yourself. The process mainly involves leveling the ground, assembling the frame, and filling the pool with water.
- In Ground Pools: Installation takes weeks or even months. Excavation, plumbing, electrical work, and curing time for concrete or fiberglass all add to the timeline. You’ll also need permits and inspections, which can slow things down.
If you want a quick backyard upgrade, above ground pools are ideal. They’re also easier to move or remove if you decide to change your setup later.
Durability and Lifespan
Durability is a key consideration if you want your pool to last many years. In ground pools generally outlast above ground pools, but there are exceptions.
- Above Ground Pools: Usually last 7 to 15 years depending on the quality of materials and maintenance. Steel or resin frames with durable liners hold up best. Harsh weather or poor upkeep can shorten lifespan.
- In Ground Pools: Can last 25 years or more. Concrete pools are the most durable but require resurfacing every 10-15 years. Fiberglass pools resist algae and stains and need less maintenance, lasting 20-30 years.
If you want a long-term investment and plan to stay in your home for many years, an in ground pool is a better choice. Above ground pools are more temporary but still offer good value for shorter-term use.
Maintenance and Upkeep
Both pool types require regular maintenance, but the effort and cost can differ.
- Above Ground Pools: Easier to maintain because of smaller size and simpler systems. You’ll still need to balance chemicals, clean filters, and remove debris. Liners may need replacement every few years.
- In Ground Pools: Require more complex maintenance. Pumps, filters, heaters, and lighting systems need regular checks. You may also need professional cleaning or repairs. Chemical balancing is crucial to prevent algae and damage.
Above ground pools are great if you want lower maintenance and fewer ongoing costs. In ground pools offer more features but demand more time and money to keep them in top shape.
Space and Aesthetic Considerations
Your backyard size and style preferences play a big role in choosing between these pools.
- Above Ground Pools: Usually smaller and round or oval shaped. They sit on top of the ground, which can limit landscaping options. However, you can add decks or fencing to improve appearance.
- In Ground Pools: Offer endless customization. You can choose any shape, size, and depth. Surrounding patios, waterfalls, and lighting create a luxurious look. They blend seamlessly into your yard.
If you want a pool that looks like a natural part of your landscape, an in ground pool is the way to go. Above ground pools are more functional and budget-friendly but less visually integrated.
Safety and Accessibility
Safety is important, especially if you have children or pets.
- Above Ground Pools: Are generally safer for kids because the elevated sides make it harder to fall in accidentally. You can add ladders that can be removed or locked.
- In Ground Pools: Require fences, covers, or alarms to prevent accidents. They are easier to access, which can be a risk without supervision.
Consider your family’s needs when deciding. Above ground pools offer a natural safety barrier, while in ground pools need extra precautions.
Environmental Impact and Energy Use
Energy efficiency and environmental impact are growing concerns for pool owners.
- Above Ground Pools: Use less water and energy due to smaller size. They often require smaller pumps and heaters.
- In Ground Pools: Consume more energy, especially if heated or equipped with lighting and water features. However, modern energy-efficient pumps and solar heating can reduce impact.
If you want a greener option, above ground pools generally have a smaller environmental footprint. But with the right upgrades, in ground pools can also be eco-friendly.
Resale Value and Home Appeal
Adding a pool can affect your home’s resale value, but the impact varies.
- Above Ground Pools: Often seen as temporary and less attractive to buyers. They may not increase home value significantly and can sometimes be viewed as a maintenance hassle.
- In Ground Pools: Usually add value, especially in warmer climates or upscale neighborhoods. A well-designed in ground pool can be a major selling point.
If you plan to sell your home soon, an in ground pool might be a better investment. Above ground pools are better for personal enjoyment without expecting a big return.
Summary Table: Above Ground vs In Ground Pools
| Feature | Above Ground Pool | In Ground Pool |
| Cost | $1,500 - $7,000 | $30,000 - $70,000+ |
| Installation Time | Few days | Weeks to months |
| Lifespan | 7 - 15 years | 25+ years |
| Maintenance | Lower | Higher |
| Customization | Limited shapes and sizes | Highly customizable |
| Safety | Elevated sides add safety | Requires fencing and alarms |
| Environmental Impact | Smaller footprint | Larger, but can be efficient |
| Resale Value | Minimal impact | Can increase home value |
Conclusion
Choosing between an above ground pool and an in ground pool depends on your budget, timeline, and how you plan to use the pool. Above ground pools are affordable, quick to install, and easier to maintain. They’re perfect if you want a simple, temporary pool for fun and relaxation.
In ground pools, on the other hand, are a bigger investment but offer durability, customization, and can boost your home’s value. They fit well if you want a permanent backyard feature that enhances your lifestyle and property.
By weighing these factors, you can pick the pool that fits your needs and enjoy many refreshing swims in your own backyard.
FAQs
What is the average lifespan of an above ground pool?
Above ground pools typically last between 7 and 15 years, depending on materials and maintenance. High-quality frames and liners can extend their life, but exposure to weather and wear will eventually require replacement.
Are in ground pools more expensive to maintain?
Yes, in ground pools usually cost more to maintain due to complex equipment like pumps, heaters, and filters. They also need regular professional cleaning and chemical balancing, which adds to ongoing expenses.
Can I install an above ground pool myself?
Many above ground pools come as kits designed for DIY installation. With basic tools and careful preparation, you can set up a pool in a few days, saving on professional installation costs.
Do above ground pools increase home value?
Above ground pools generally do not add significant value to a home and may be seen as less desirable by buyers. In ground pools tend to have a more positive impact on resale value.
Which pool type is safer for children?
Above ground pools are often safer for children because their elevated sides reduce the risk of accidental falls. In ground pools require additional safety measures like fences and covers to protect kids.
